C H

 The split between Carnatic and Hindustani music in Indian classical tradition is deeply tied to historical, cultural, and geographical factors that unfolded over centuries.

1. Historical Context

The division became pronounced around the 13th century, during the Delhi Sultanate and subsequent Mughal Empire. The north of India came under significant Persian and Central Asian cultural influence due to Islamic conquests.

The South, governed by empires like the Cholas, Pandyas, Vijayanagara, and Nayakas, remained relatively insulated from these influences and retained its indigenous traditions.

2. Geographical Separation

Northern India developed a distinct musical style under Persian and Mughal patronage, blending Indian traditions with Persian and Central Asian music. This evolved into Hindustani music.

Southern India, unaffected by this cultural integration, preserved the older, purer forms of Indian music, leading to the evolution of Carnatic music.

3. Philosophical and Religious Differences

Hindustani music absorbed Persian and Islamic influences, incorporating instruments like the sitar and tabla and adopting forms like ghazals and qawwalis. The focus often shifted to secular themes like love and mysticism alongside devotional music.

Carnatic music remained deeply tied to Hindu religious traditions and is predominantly devotional, with compositions focusing on gods and scriptures.

4. Theoretical Differences

Raga and Tala Systems: Both traditions use the raga (melodic framework) and tala (rhythmic cycles) systems, but their execution differs.

Hindustani music often emphasizes improvisation and the exploration of a raga's mood over an extended period.

Carnatic music is more structured, with an emphasis on compositions and kritis (songs).

Theoretical treatises like the Brihaddeshi by Matanga (6th–8th century) and the Sangeeta Ratnakara by Sarangadeva (13th century) are common to both styles. However, later works like the Chaturdandi Prakasika (Carnatic) and Raga Darpan (Hindustani) diverged.

5. Key Figures

In Hindustani music, notable figures include Tansen (a court musician of Akbar) and his successors, who shaped the gharana system.

In Carnatic music, composers like Purandara Dasa (the "Father of Carnatic Music") and the Trinity of Carnatic Music—Tyagaraja, Muthuswami Dikshitar, and Shyama Sastri—codified the tradition.

6. Instruments

Hindustani music features instruments like the sitar, sarod, tabla, and harmonium.

Carnatic music uses instruments like the veena, mridangam, violin, and flute.

7. Performance Styles

Hindustani concerts often include long alap sections (slow introductions to a raga), followed by compositions and improvisations.

Carnatic concerts are more structured, starting with a varnam (introductory piece) and progressing through kritis, ragam-tanam-pallavi, and devotional songs.

The split between Hindustani and Carnatic music reflects the broader cultural and historical divergence between northern and southern India. Despite their differences, both traditions share common roots and have contributed immensely to the diversity and richness of Indian classical music.